Strange Horizons, July 2002 Page 6
Fred Saberhagen confers much the same advantages upon Count Dracula in The Dracula Tape and its sequels. Saberhagen retells the events of Stoker's novel from the viewpoint of the vampire. Setting the record straight in his own words, Dracula presents himself as a ruthless but thoroughly honorable nobleman, the victim of misrepresentation and harassment by the fanatical Van Helsing—this Dracula appears a “reasonable fellow ... of a superior intellect and even good will toward mere humans,” in the words of one critic (Wilgus, 93). Contrary to popular belief, he derives most of his nourishment from animal blood. He drinks from Lucy and Mina, who come to him of their own free will, not out of hunger but out of erotic passion. “The love of women I have known all my life and for me its essence does not change,” the Count explains. “But its mode of expression had changed when I awoke from my mortal wounds of 1476. Since then, for me, the blood is all” (Saberhagen, 37).
And though this author does not make the claim in so many words, Saberhagen clearly implies the superiority of vampire sex, since Lucy reaches orgasm from Dracula's bite alone. Dracula is also exogamous in this inversion of Stoker's story; he wants to postpone Mina's transformation because it would then constitute “incest, and worse, for us to try to suck each other's veins” (Saberhagen, 144)—a striking anticipation of Stevenson's thesis. P. N. Elrod, whose model of vampirism resembles Saberhagen's, has her vampire protagonist explain, “The pleasure centers and how they operated had drastically shifted [since his transformation]” (Elrod, 24). In this novel the heroine explicitly states her preference for vampire sex because, “When you do it this way, it just goes on and on” (Elrod, 25); again, a vampire lover is portrayed as transcending the human male's sexual limitations. The supernatural vampire as presented in contemporary fiction, rather than representing a male adolescent sexual fantasy as Twitchell maintains, might more accurately be characterized as a quintessentially female fantasy.
Not all contemporary supernatural vampires, of course, share the traditional incapacity for genital intercourse. In movies, particularly, such as Blacula and Love at First Bite, this convention is often ignored. David M. Van Becker discusses a number of potent vampires in “Dracula's Impotence Cured?” Van Becker views this counter-trend as part of the recent “humanization, socialization, and domestication” of the vampire. Frequently, along with the abandonment of the impotence convention, traditional folkloric traits of the vampire are eliminated or downplayed. References to the unpleasant facts of death, or undeath, fade into the background. According to Van Becker, vampires subjected to this revisionist process tend to become “mock humans.” The author has the widest scope for revision, naturally, when he or she writes science fiction rather than horror-fantasy and attempts to fit the vampire into the natural order as we know it.
In this kind of fiction, what becomes of the vampire's traditional sexual appeal? Different authors, depending on what rationale they employ, use different strategies to preserve the vampire's allure under changed conditions. We may conveniently divide science fiction vampires into two categories, exogamous, preferring human sexual partners, and endogamous, able and/or preferring to mate with their own kind. As we might expect, exogamous naturalistic vampires can retain much of the sexual magnetism we associate with Carmilla, Dracula, and their descendants.
We have already mentioned Lichtenberg's Those of My Blood, in which vampires are members of an alien species, the luren, marooned on Earth. Since the protagonist, Titus, is a human-luren hybrid, he does not take on vampiric traits until his apparent death, whereupon his transformation—including the onset of sexual maturity—occurs. His skill as a lover springs partly from the vampiric power of Influence, a kind of irresistible super-hypnosis. With his true love Inea, however, he uses no Influence but leaves her will free.
Like Saint-Germain and Saberhagen's Dracula, he requires his partner's ardent response for his own satisfaction and therefore must confer ecstasy upon her as an inescapable corollary of his need. “He took his time, following the body currents, stimulating each and every bit of skin and deep muscle, until the currents of orgasm would move unobstructed by tension” (Lichtenberg, 119). Only then can her “ectoplasm,” which nourishes him, flow into him unimpeded. His vampire nature also makes his sexual attentions more satisfying than an ordinary man's because “his hunger sharpened the experience for his bedmates, even when he used no Influence” (Lichtenberg, 95). Again the allure of the alien and the feminine fantasy of the ideally considerate lover work together to make the character erotically fascinating.
The Varkela, a people of the Russian steppes created by Susan Petrey in a series of novellas in the Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, perhaps the only unequivocally good vampires in fiction, pride themselves on their shamanistic healing talent and their superhuman skill with horses. Though, like Lichtenberg's luren, the Varkela possess an innate hypnotic power, they use it mainly for healing and seldom for seduction. They drink token amounts of blood from women in the act of love and sometimes offer their own blood in return, as Dracula does in Stoker's novel (and, with explicit eroticism, in Saberhagen's). After the heroine of “Leechcraft” tastes the blood of Valance, her Varkela lover, “For an instant it seemed as if she saw herself through his eyes.... ‘Our souls have touched,’ he said” (Petrey, 29). Vampiric love permits a union unknown to ordinary people.
By now we should not be surprised that Myrna finds Valance “the most sensitive lover she had ever known” (Petrey, 29). Similar attributes belong to the family of alien vampires in Elaine Bergstrom's Shattered Glass. Bergstrom's vampires possess superhuman sexual skill because they are telepathic; in the novel's opening scene, the renegade vampire pleasures his victim “perfectly—as she would herself” (Bergstrom, 3). These creatures, moreover, project a psychic magnetism that draws human beings to them even without conscious intent on the vampires’ part. This attraction is explicitly the allure of the Other, for as Helen, a vampire-human hybrid, grows into her vampiric heritage, her vampire lover becomes less satisfying to her.
Miriam, in Whitley Strieber's The Hunger, also wields telepathic power that makes her erotic attentions superhumanly irresistible to both men and women. Since she is the last of her species, she is exogamous by necessity. She tries repeatedly to end her isolation by transforming human victims into her likeness, an attempt never completely successful. Her essential solitude dominates the novel. “She was lonely and human beings gave her the love that pets give” (Strieber, 64). Later, speculating about the near-extinction of her kind, she attributes it to the dangerous seductiveness of humanity: “If one loved human beings, how could one also kill them and still be happy enough with oneself to love one's own kind, and bear young?” (Strieber, 189). Since the author dwells upon Miriam's futile craving for true companionship, her destructive exploitation of her donors as experimental subjects does not destroy the reader's sympathy for her.
When an author chooses to create endogamous vampires, the traditional erotic interest is less readily available. Therefore the vampire's attraction in this kind of fiction tends to spring from isolation and loneliness, arousing sympathy as in The Hunger, and from the allure of the Other. For example, Clifford, the nonhuman, scientifically rationalized vampire of Bob Leman's novella, “The Pilgrimage of Clifford M.,” exemplifies extreme isolation. His kind share less in common with Homo sapiens than do any other alien vampires I am aware of. They begin life as voracious den-dwelling carnivores, more like fetuses than fully formed animals, except for their fur and shark-like teeth. After a lengthy childhood, befitting their long lives, they grow into an outwardly human shape and become nocturnal creatures living exclusively on blood. Even then, however, their nonhuman genitalia and the female's multiple nipples preclude any sexual intimacy with human beings. The novella centers on Clifford's search for other members of his species, for he was accidentally separated from his parents and brought up by human beings. One motive for this quest is “simple lust; but lust for whom, for what? Not any woman th
at he had ever met; not any man or child or beast. This most urgent drive was toward a female of his own kind” (Leman, 18).
Therefore eroticism plays no part in Clifford's appeal to the reader. Instead, Leman elicits sympathy by dwelling on Clifford's search for self-knowledge and the companionship of his own people. Once he attains adulthood, Clifford becomes circumspect, never killing or even seriously harming his victims. Leading the life of a wealthy recluse, he pursues his quest until he finds a group of three vampires in a rural mountain community, probably the last remaining vampires in North America. He now discovers that adult vampires gradually devolve into nearly mindless predators, “diurnally lying comatose in a muddy burrow, awakening only to prey disgustingly upon human beings” (Leman, 27). This discovery extinguishes Clifford's unfulfilled lust, making his sexual isolation complete.
Similarly, his social isolation is complete, for he can be neither a true vampire nor a true human being. Having joined forces with a group of small-town vampire hunters, he directs them to the den of the wild vampires, where he himself lies waiting to be killed as well. He had visualized vampires, he realizes, as “cultivated humans who possessed—as it happened—certain nocturnal proclivities, and who required a somewhat specialized diet” (Leman, 30). He cannot face life with the creatures he has actually found, yet he knows that eventually “my mind would have failed, as theirs have, and my body would have gone on and on, year by year becoming more bestial and loathsome” (Leman, 30). Leman foregrounds Clifford's loneliness by casting the last two pages of the novella as a suicide letter from Clifford to the vampire-hunters he has induced to kill him. The vampire longs for communication and self-disclosure as well as self-knowledge.
Another alien vampire separated from his people in childhood and forced to discover his own nature unaided is Joshua York of George R. R. Martin's Fevre Dream. Unlike most fictional vampires, Joshua's kind crave blood only once a month, but at that period their uncontrollable bloodlust drives them to kill. Once reunited with members of his species, Joshua devotes his life to discovering an artificial blood substitute to quell the thirst. Thus Joshua appeals to the reader as a sympathetic figure because he hates killing and eventually becomes free of the need to do so. Like Clifford, Joshua is endogamous, unable to mate with human women. Male vampires in Fevre Dream are potent only in the presence of a female in estrus, an event that occurs very infrequently. Joshua therefore enlists the reader's pity because of his sexual isolation; freed from the monthly feeding frenzy, he has no chance to mate, since normally estrus follows the sharing of a kill.
Only at the novel's conclusion do Joshua and one of his female allies develop to the point where they can mate in the absence of the feeding frenzy. Aside from Joshua's loneliness in childhood, his sexual isolation, and his dislike of violence, he appeals to the reader because, like Clifford, he reaches out to a human being. A central segment of the novel consists of Joshua's telling the story of his youth to a Mississippi steamboat captain he befriends. In this episode both Joshua and Captain Marsh are clearly motivated by the allure of the Other. “'I have never told the truth to one of you before,'” says Joshua. “'To one of the cattle,’ Marsh grumbled. ‘Well, I never lissened to no vampire before neither, so we're even. Go on. This here bull is lissenin'” (Martin, 144). Both of them long for honest communication, leading to a “true partnership” between members of the two species (Martin, 144).
Joan Gordon points out that several recent vampire novels focus on “cross-species responsibility with its implications about ecology and human relations” and the problem of “how to behave when confronted by our first alien being” (Gordon, 231). One novel addresses these issues more directly than any tale so far mentioned—The Vampire Tapestry, by Suzy McKee Charnas. Moreover, Charnas’ novel, a connected series of five novellas leading us into ever-deepening intimacy with the alien vampire protagonist, appeals to the reader by addressing the human desire to know the mind of the Other, hinted at in Fevre Dream and explored in Anne Rice's Interview with the Vampire.
J. R. R. Tolkien, in “On Fairy-Stories,” identifies this wish as a perennial human longing. Fairy tales, he says, are valued because they provide the imaginary “satisfaction of certain primordial human desires,” among them the yearning “to hold communion with other living things” (Tolkien, 41). Like the classic vampire, we mortals suffer from isolation, too, for “other creatures are like other realms with which Man has broken off relations, and sees now only from the outside at a distance” (Tolkien, 84). As the very title of the central section of Charnas’ novel, “Unicorn Tapestry,” suggests, this link between supernatural fantasy and fairy tales is especially relevant to Charnas’ treatment of vampirism.
Charnas’ vampire, Dr. Weyland, is unique and solitary, apparently the sole survivor of a vampire species, so old that he remembers no parents or childhood. Hence he carries to the ultimate degree the isolation traditionally attributed to the vampire. When the dangers or pressures of a particular era becoming overwhelming, he retreats into suspended animation and sleeps until conditions change enough to make it safe for him to rise to a new life. During each long sleep he forgets the details of his previous lifetime, though general knowledge and skills carry over.
The Vampire Tapestry traces a period of development in self-knowledge that undermines his ruthless predatory nature, renders him dangerously introspective, and causes him to begin caring about his human prey. Rather than lose what he regards as his essential self, Weyland chooses to withdraw into the long sleep. As a protean creature who assumes whatever character best suits his goals during each lifetime, he does not even have a name; it is noteworthy that in the last scene of the book, as soon as he has decided to abandon his “Weyland” persona, the author ceases to call him by name.
Applying our exogamous/endogamous categories to Weyland, we find that he fits well into neither. With no other vampires in existence, he cannot mate endogamously. On the other hand, he feels no desire to copulate with human beings, though he occasionally does so for pragmatic reasons. Sexual allure, therefore, should not be a part of Weyland's appeal as a fictional character. Yet, despite his scorn for vampire fans guilty of “mixing up dinner with sex” (Charnas, 28) and his contemptuous remark, “Would you mate with your livestock?” (Charnas, 138), Carol Senf still includes Weyland among fictional vampires “described as sensuous and physically ardent” (Senf, 8). Women characters within the novel display similar reactions to him. His female graduate assistant says of her desire for him, “next time somebody says they climb mountains because they're there, I'll have some idea what they mean” (Charnas, 237). His psychotherapist, Floria Landauer, unwillingly finds herself sexually aroused by his description of feeding and asks herself, “How come this attraction to someone so scary?” (Charnas, 135).
Floria later concludes that she is drawn to Weyland because he seems exempt from the confusions of ordinary human life: “All springs from, elaborates, the single, stark, primary condition: he is a predator who subsists on human blood. Harmony, strength, clarity, magnificence—all from that basic animal integrity” (Charnas, 160). Her desire for him, then, is not rooted simply in his rugged physical charm, but in the lure of the Other. This lure is first made explicit when she asks him to speak for her, to state his perception of her attitude toward him. He draws an analogy between his condition and that of the unicorn, who can be trapped only by a maiden: “Unicorn, come lay your head in my lap while the hunters close in. You are a wonder, and for love of wonder I will tame you” (Charnas, 161).
When he decides to leave New York, reclaiming and destroying the case notes Floria has kept, she persuades him not to kill her, a task made easier by Weyland's own reluctance to do so. Though Weyland does not admit the fact to himself at this point, he has begun to care for her as an individual. “How did you grow so real?” he asks her. “The more I spoke to you of myself, the more real you became” (Charnas, 175). Even a solitary predator needs the Other against which to define himself.
Earlier, Floria has suggested to him that “beneath your various facades your true self ... wants, needs to be honored as real and valuable through acceptance by another. I try to be that other” (Charnas, 160).
At their final meeting, she invites him to go to bed with her. He accepts, clearly not out of lust (she has to stimulate him manually), but out of an attraction toward the Other like the attraction she feels toward him—"She lived the fantasy of sex with an utter stranger” (Charnas, 176). Weyland admits to being motivated by curiosity. Later, in a letter written but never sent, he speculates on why he desired this union with her. Perhaps, he thinks, he wanted to “repossess a part of myself I had unwittingly given you,” or perhaps to “touch a part of you that our speaking together had revealed to me” (Charnas, 252).
This process of touching an alien mind constitutes one of the most powerful attractions of contemporary vampire fiction. When the bloodthirsty revenant of legend becomes rationalized into a member of another species, literalizing the metaphor of vampire as ultimate foreigner that Stevenson sees in Dracula, we get a glimpse into a mode of being somehow both human and nonhuman. When we cannot prejudge the vampire as satanically evil, because he is merely obeying the dictates of natural law, we can embrace his otherness and enjoy a fascination similar to yet not identical with the traditional erotic appeal. If the creators of such characters do their work well, their vampires, rather than “mock humans” (in Van Becker's phrase) are alien beings just human enough to be comprehensible. In the words of Floria Landauer, we vicariously experience “unlike closing with unlike across whatever likeness may be found” (Charnas, 178).